Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. is a precious and revealing tale written by Judy Blume about growing up a little different. Margaret Simon, the main character, has just moved from bustling New York City to a much quieter suburban town (Margaret's grandmother, Sylvia, would describe as country) in New Jersey. Margaret, months away from turning twelve, is naturally nervous. She immediately meets a well-intentioned, extraverted girl around the same age as her, Nancy Wheeler. Nancy seems to have no filter, but graciously takes Margaret under her wing and invites her to join her secret club after the first day of school. What Nancy lacks in delicacy and charm, she makes up for in savviness. Nancy knows all about what's cool, what's not, and what Margaret needs to do to fit in. This becomes our greatest driving force for the story's plot.
Margaret is the perfect vessel for learning about the standard pre-teen experience. I saw a lot of myself in her, and I'm sure other former-pre-teens would say the same. She feels left out of her family's major decision-making moments (like moving), keeps significant qualities about herself to herself, and generally seems to be wriggling for her own space while trying to keep her world easy to navigate. She's assertive and trying to grow up with the least amount of pushback possible.
"I love the way people always think they know somebody your age until you tell them how old you really are!"
I've been told many times throughout my life that to be intelligent is a very lonely thing. As we continue through the story, I was reminded of my own first twinges of discomfort as I began to learn from experience the truth of that, as Margaret does. We all, I'm sure, have tried to ignore or cut off or hide parts of who we are in an effort to connect a little better with others. Margaret is learning this via her spiritual experience. While the other families in her new community were all religious (either attending the Y or the Jewish Community Center), Margaret comes from an unreligious family and does not attend either. This excites the other girls in her secret club (the Four PTS's, or The Four Pre-Teen Sensations) and inspires them to bring the subject a little further than she'd have liked. When Margaret mentions in a writing prompt in class that she hates religious holidays (it's inferred that this is because of the familial pressure she experiences, as her mother comes from a devout Christian family and father a devout Jewish family, neither approving of the other) he pulls her aside and questions her for it. Margaret, in fact, has a much more personal and private relationship with God. She prays to him like they were on a first-name, comfortable basis. This is something she doesn't reveal to her parents or over-bearing grandmother, in an effort to avoid their reactions. Her uniqueness leads to confusion, fascination, and lots of prying from others. I wanted to step into the book and say, "Girl, I get you! Let's ditch these freaks and grab some gelato".
On the rhetorical style of Judy Blume, I want to lead by stating that she is an absolute artist. Blume is an extraordinarily talented writer, and I believe her numerous works should be a staple in every household filled with children aged seven-twelve years old at least. She captures the youthful tone perfectly. While I was surprised to find a few simple typos throughout the book (come on! This is Judy Blume! She should have had some stellar editors backing her up), it's very clear that she cared deeply about her work. This was most certainly not a cheaply put together book for kids written by someone who just wanted to be able to brag about being published like we often find in more modern books. There was a lot of thought put into every detail and (brief, easy to read) chapter.
Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret. is a splendid book. I really did enjoy reading it and reliving many moments in my own pre-teenhood. I'd recommend it to:
-Children aged seven through thirteen, for certain. They'll find a relatable character between the covers who shares similar concerns and finds similar solutions. Perhaps the perspective Margaret has will help them to evaluate their own!
-Adults in need of a dose of nostalgia or the opportunity to send a warm hug to their younger self. I know that this story provided me an opportunity to reflect on who I was at this age and send her some love.
-Anyone working in K-12 education. Especially those who teach in grades 4-8. This story will help you to empathize with your students and understand where they're coming from, as well as reflect on how quickly things have changed (and very much stayed the same) since 1970. This reflection, I believe, helps educators to greater understand the student psyche and how to serve their students.
-Parents. Intentional or not (I haven't decided yet, but I'm leaning towards absolutely intentional), Blume highlights many of the common parenting mistakes and mishandlings committed against pre-teens and teens. For example, Barbara Simon (Margaret's mom) has a habit of telling Margaret that she's going to be too much to handle when she's a teenager. This kind of rhetoric towards a child tends to make them feel disconnected, unwanted, guilty, and often sets the parent-child relationship during teenhood up for failure. Parents who really tap into their intuition can easily observe this as they read this book and many others pertaining to childhood.
-Anyone looking for a charming, yet impactful read!




